Welcome to JB Cookie Cutters’ Pilgrim Thanksgiving Cookie Cutters page! Here, you’ll find a delightful selection of cookie cutters that are perfect for adding some Thanksgiving charm to your baking. These high-quality cookie cutters are made from durable materials and feature intricate designs that capture the spirit and essence of the pilgrim era.

Whether you’re baking for a Thanksgiving feast, a historical reenactment, or just for fun, these cookie cutters are sure to impress. We offer a variety of different pilgrim-inspired shapes and sizes, including pilgrim hats, bonnets, and pumpkins, making it easy to create a whole batch of festive cookies.

At JB Cookie Cutters, we’re committed to providing our customers with the best selection of cookie cutters available. Our Pilgrim Thanksgiving Cookie Cutters are no exception, and they’re sure to provide hours of creative fun in the kitchen. So why not add some historical flair to your next batch of cookies with JB Cookie Cutters’ Pilgrim Thanksgiving Cookie Cutters?

Thanksgiving - Pilgrim Girl 266-A955 Cookie Cutter Set
Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Girl 266-A955 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Girl 266-A955 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain … Read More

$5.50$9.50
Select options
Pilgrim Boy 100 Cookie Cutter Set
Pilgrim Boy 100 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Pilgrim Boy 100 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters … Read More

not rated $5.50$9.50
Select options
Pilgrim Hat 102 Cookie Cutter Set
Pilgrim Hat 102 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Pilgrim Hat 102 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters … Read More

not rated $5.50$8.50
Select options
Christmas Main
Christmas Cookie Cutter Bundle

Our Christmas Cookie Cutter Bundle is perfect for preparing your holiday cookies. Cut them out and decorate with your favorite royal icing (the ones shown in our product photo were made with our 4 inch size).   This bundle will … Read More

not rated $4.50$8.50
Select options
Thanksgiving - Pilgrim Hat 266-F736 Cookie Cutter Set
Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Hat 266-F736 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Hat 266-F736 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain … Read More

not rated $7.50$9.50
Select options
Owl Pilgrim 100 Cookie Cutter Set
Owl Pilgrim 100 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Owl Pilgrim 100 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters … Read More

not rated $5.50$9.50
Select options
Owl Pilgrim 101 Cookie Cutter Set
Owl Pilgrim 101 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Owl Pilgrim 101 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters … Read More

not rated $5.50$9.50
Select options
Thanksgiving Main
Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter Bundle

Our Thanksgiving Cookie Cutter Bundle is perfect for preparing your holiday cookies. Cut them out and decorate with your favorite royal icing (the ones shown in our product photo were made with our 4 inch size).   This bundle will … Read More

not rated $4.50$8.50
Select options
Native American Girl 100 Cookie Cutter Set
Native American Girl 100 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Native American Girl 100 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie … Read More

not rated $5.50$8.50
Select options
Thanksgiving - Turkey in Pilgrim Hat 266-F751 Cookie Cutter Set
Thanksgiving – Turkey in Pilgrim Hat 266-F751 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Thanksgiving – Turkey in Pilgrim Hat 266-F751 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered … Read More

not rated $5.50$9.50
Select options
Pilgrim Mickey 266-A419 Cookie Cutter Set
Pilgrim Mickey 266-A419 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Pilgrim Mickey 266-A419 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters … Read More

not rated $5.50$8.50
Select options
Bear Pilgrim Cookie Cutter Set
Bear Pilgrim Cookie Cutter Set

Our Bear Pilgrim Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain cookie cutters can … Read More

not rated $5.50$8.50
Select options
Thanksgiving - Pilgrim Hat 266-I125 Cookie Cutter Silhouette
Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Hat 266-I125 Cookie Cutter Silhouette

Our Thanksgiving – Pilgrim Hat 266-I125 Cookie Cutter Silhouette is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain … Read More

not rated $3.00$6.00
Select options
Thanksgiving - Pilgrims Kissing 266-F753 Cookie Cutter Set
Thanksgiving – Pilgrims Kissing 266-F753 Cookie Cutter Set

Our Thanksgiving – Pilgrims Kissing 266-F753 Cookie Cutter Set is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. Certain … Read More

not rated $5.50$8.50
Select options
Thanksgiving - Pilgrim with Turkey 266-F740 Cookie Cutter Silhouette
Thanksgiving – Pilgrim with Turkey 266-F740 Cookie Cutter Silhouette

Our Thanksgiving – Pilgrim with Turkey 266-F740 Cookie Cutter Silhouette is primarily made to cut fondant to decorate treats such as cookies, cupcakes, cakes, rice krispie treats, sandwich cookies, cake pops, chocolate dipped strawberries, candy apples, and chocolate covered marshmallows. … Read More

not rated $4.00$6.00
Select options